One girl is killed and two other girls injured in a hit-and-run with a drunk driver. The incident created quite a spectacle in the community, involving a suspicious medical exam, two NYC night club “entertainers,” a former-prohibition-agent-turned-speakeasy-owner (and his thuggish bartender), death threats, and a possible police cover-up.
This is a series of articles in Pop’s scrapbook. It apparently affected him enough that he kept every article that was written about this incident.
On August 25, 1932, Evelyn Kelly, Gertrude Pugh, and Dorothy Balmain were walking together along Edgewater Avenue when they were struck by a vehicle driven by Harvey Lyons.
Evelyn Kelly was about 15 years old. Her father was Michael Kelly, a newspaper employee, and her mother was Veronica. She had three brothers and a sister. The family lived on Edgewater Avenue, only a few feet from where the girls were struck down.
Gertrude Pugh was also around 15 years old. She lived with her mother Harriet and two siblings: a sister and a brother.
Dorothy Balmain was 14 years old. She lived with her mother, Irene (Seaman) Balmain – a widowed telephone operator – her brother Robert, and her sister Frances, both several years older. Dorothy’s father, Robert, worked in a saloon before his death. He and Irene were married 24 Oct 1907 in Kings County, NY.
Harvey Lyons was born in New Jersey on 27 Feb 1889 to parents William Lyons and Ida Truax.1 2 At the time of the incident, he was a 40-year-old truck driver. He apparently had no children, but was first married to a woman named Sarah, then to a woman named Florence (to whom he was married at the time of this incident). He was driving the vehicle involved in this incident, and apparently had three passengers: Robert Berry, Anita Corbin, and Dorothy McCoy.
Anita Corbin and Dorothy McCoy were both 22 years old and worked at a night club in New York. They lived at the Hotel Embassy at 70th and Broadway in New York City.
Harry Eicholz was a lunch stand operator in Ridgefield.
Ridgely Armstrong was a former Prohibition Agent, and at the time of the incident was the proprietor of the Ridgefield Inn on Bergen Turnpike.
John Mannion was bartender at the Ridgefield Inn on the night of the incident.
Dr. John V. Lynn was the physician who examined Mr. Lyons at 10:30 p.m. on the night of the incident.
Sgt. Charles Erickson and Patrolman William Heilman were members of the Ridgefield Police department. Sgt. Erickson was working the desk the night of the incident. Heilman was one of the officers searching the area of the incident during the investigation.
Coming Up Next: Part 2 – What actually happened?
- “New Jersey Births and Christenings, 1660-1980,” database, FamilySearch(https://familysearch.org/ark:/61903/1:1:FCLB-MY3 : accessed 22 November 2015), Harvey M. Lyons, 27 Feb 1889; citing Rfd., Bergen, New Jersey, reference v 31 p 46; FHL microfilm 494,213. ↩
- His WWI draft card says he was born in 1890. ↩